Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) describe security fatigue as a weariness or reluctance to deal with computer security. Their study, published in IEEE's IT Professional in 2016, treats it as a form of decision fatigue, the drop in decision quality that follows being asked to make too many choices, applied to security prompts and rules.

NIST's summary of the findings links that weariness to avoiding decisions, choosing the easiest option, acting on impulse, and failing to follow security rules. Healthcare staff receive security warnings, training assignments, and simulated phishing emails in the same inbox they use for patient care, so every addition to a training program becomes one more decision in that queue.

Read more: What HIPAA actually requires for security awareness training | Introducing Paubox Security Awareness Training | What is social engineering?

 

What NIST's interviews found

Brian Stanton, Mary Theofanos, Sandra Spickard Prettyman, and Susanne Furman drew on in-depth interviews with 40 computer users from the Washington, DC area and central Pennsylvania, ranging in age from their 20s to their 60s. The interviews covered work and home computer use, online activity, security terminology, and security tools.

Fatigue was not the subject of the original study. Theofanos, a NIST computer scientist and co-author, said the team found "an overwhelming feeling of weariness throughout all of the data" anyway.

Participants described resignation and a loss of control over their own security. Many said they didn't feel important enough to be targeted and didn't know anyone who had been hacked, and some described protecting their data as somebody else's responsibility, such as their bank or a person with more experience.

 

Who NIST said this affects

NIST pointed to workers who use computers but for whom security is not their primary responsibility, including people who protect personally identifiable information in fields such as health care, finance, and education. That description covers most of a clinical and administrative workforce.

Stanton, a cognitive psychologist at NIST and co-author of the study, summarized the consequence in the agency's announcement. "If people can't use security, they are not going to," he said.

 

What clinicians say about the burden

A Delphi study of clinicians, a method that gathers expert opinion over several structured rounds, found broad agreement that security matters. According to the study, published in PMC, 96% of participants considered cybersecurity in healthcare critical for protecting data.

The same participants named the obstacles. Time and resource constraints were the top challenge to putting cybersecurity measures in place at 65%, followed by disruption to workflows and services at 60.4%. The group was drawn from physicians, dentists, nurses, pharmacists, and allied health professionals.

 

NIST's three recommendations

NIST's announcement listed three ways to ease security fatigue drawn from the data:

  • Limit the number of security decisions users need to make.
  • Make it simple for users to choose the right security action.
  • Design for consistent decision making wherever possible.

Each of these applies to a training program as much as to software. A program that sends every employee the same frequent assignments adds decisions for staff who don't need them, while one that directs follow-up to the people who struggle keeps the load lower for everyone else.

 

Applying the recommendations with Paubox

Filtering removes decisions before staff ever face them. Paubox Inbound Email Security reads sender behavior and message intent to stop phishing before it reaches an inbox, so fewer suspicious messages need an employee's judgment in the first place. Paubox Security Awareness Training can run a simulation automatically each month on an unpredictable schedule, without administrators building every campaign by hand. Its reports distinguish employees who only opened a test message from those who clicked and those who typed in credentials, which lets extra training go to the smaller group that needs it. Both run in the same account as Paubox's HIPAA compliant email encryption, which applies to outbound messages without staff deciding whether each one needs protection.

Learn more: Paubox Security Awareness Training | Paubox Inbound Email Security | Paubox Email Suite

 

What a survey of healthcare staff found during the pandemic

A survey of 200 healthcare professionals, including nurses, executives, and IT staff, looked at communication tools and burnout during the COVID-19 pandemic. Cybersecurity Dive reported that nearly three-quarters were concerned patient health information was being sent through unsecured tools, with 15% extremely concerned. The vast majority said the pandemic had increased burnout, especially among clinicians. Respondents also addressed alarm fatigue, the desensitization that follows constant clinical alerts, and mostly blamed heavy workloads and poor integration into clinical workflow for it.

 

FAQs

What is security fatigue?

NIST researchers define it as a weariness or reluctance to deal with computer security. They describe it as decision fatigue applied to security, which leads people to avoid decisions, choose the easiest option, or skip security rules.

 

Does security fatigue apply to healthcare workers?

NIST named workers for whom security isn't their primary job, including those protecting personal information in health care. A Delphi study of clinicians found time constraints and workflow disruption were the top obstacles to cybersecurity measures.

 

How often should healthcare staff be trained?

HIPAA requires a security awareness and training program but sets no frequency. NIST's recommendations favor limiting the number of security decisions staff face, which argues for targeting extra training rather than adding it for everyone.

 

How can an organization reduce the decisions staff makes?

Email filtering that stops phishing before delivery removes many decisions, and encryption that applies automatically removes the choice of whether to protect each message.

 

How does Paubox Security Awareness Training fit NIST's advice?

Automatic monthly campaigns reduce administrative work, and reports separating opens, clicks, and credential entry let follow-up training go only to the employees who need it.