IT impersonation is a strategy that works for malicious actors because staff expect IT to ask them to log in, reset a password, or approve a device. In many cases, no password is cracked and no system is hacked. An employee or help desk agent hands over access.
Researchers in a JAMA Network Open study analyzed data from six US health care organizations from 2011 to 2018. They collected data from 95 simulated phishing campaigns, and 2.9 million emails were sent to employees. They found that when the phishing email was impersonating IT, it had a median click rate of 18.6%. Help desk workers should call the employee back on the number on file before any password reset or device enrollment, as the 2024 health sector alert recommended. Overall, the researchers found "almost 1 in 7 simulated emails sent were clicked on by employees."
Any business that sends lab results or patient referrals and bills via HIPAA compliant email should know this. If someone impersonates your IT department and an employee hands over a login, the attacker can read everything in the mailbox, including PHI sent through an encrypted email platform.
Why a message from IT gets opened
The phishing emails in the study from JAMA Network Open were simple. One informed the employee they had exceeded their mailbox size. Another stated their account was going to be deleted if they didn't take action. These are emails that an IT department would send to an employee.
A study at a Norwegian hospital, published in 2026, described phishing as "exploiting psychological factors such as urgency and authority." In the test, 396 of 753 employees who were not included in the test groups clicked the link. It’s a 53% click rate. Again, this was one test done at one hospital with one phishing email.
The same could be said about the data from the US as well. Once the researchers controlled for site, year, and number of campaigns, personal emails, such as an e-card, were the most likely to be clicked. IT-themed emails get clicks, but the data does not show they are the most effective lure. So impersonating an IT employee will get someone to click, but we don't know if it's the most effective method.
How the attack moves between the inbox and the help desk
Someone can impersonate your IT department to your employees or impersonate an employee to your IT department.
In an alert sent to the health care industry in April 2024, the Health Sector Cybersecurity Coordination Center reported someone called into a hospital's IT help desk from a local phone number. They stated they worked for the hospital and gave the last four digits of an employee's Social Security number and their employee number. They claimed their phone was broken and asked the help desk to add them to MFA on a new device.
Once the device was added to the employee's account, the caller could gain access to their email and payor portals. They then sent a notice to redirect payments to an account they controlled.
Read also: Attackers flood the inbox to set up the vishing call
What an impersonator finds inside a mailbox
According to the Paubox report, The top 3 healthcare email attacks in 2025 and how to defend against them, 170 email-related breaches in 2025 affected 2.5 million people. Phishing-driven mailbox takeovers made up approximately 17% of those breaches and exposed around 630,000 individuals.
When phishing was used to gain access to an employee's email account it accounted for approximately 17% of the breaches and left around 630,000 individuals vulnerable.
They list impersonating your IT department as one of the types of phishing that occurred in 2025. It also lists impersonating an executive and your vendors. Some of these phishing attacks did not have any malware on them. They simply took advantage of an employee's "inherited trust" with certain programs. Once they had access to the employee's email, they searched through previous messages for billing, referral and lab terms. They then created inbox rules to either forward or hide those messages.
If you are a referral coordinator and you typed your credentials into what you thought was a password reset page, you could have months of referrals to specialists in your sent folder. Each one contains the patient’s name, the reason for the referral, and the ordering physician.
Workload predicts clicks better than good intentions
Researchers writing in the Journal of Medical Internet Research compared survey responses and click rates from 397 hospital employees. They found no notable correlation between clicking on phishing emails and an employee’s intention to follow security policies. Workload did correlate with clicking.
After further research, the authors concluded "intention and compliance might not be as strongly linked as previously assumed." Just because someone had more on their plate doesn't mean they are going to click on phishing emails. But there is a correlation there.
If a nurse is working through their inbox at the end of their shift and has patient instructions to send out, they may be the person who clicks on a phishing email impersonating your IT department.
Tailored requests are harder to refuse
In a case study at an Italian hospital with 6,000 employees, researchers found a customized phishing email was “much more likely to be acted on” than a generic one. They sent out a generic phishing email, and 64% of the staff did not open it. When they personalized the email, only 38% of the staff did not open the email.
There is information available online that attackers can use to personalize these phishing emails. During a study at a children's hospital in the UK, they were able to find 468 employees' email addresses online. No employees' logins were obtained during this test. But they still concluded healthcare professionals had "limited awareness of threats."
If an attacker can impersonate your IT department with your EHR vendor's name and your help desk number, they are going to be taken seriously.
What HIPAA expects when a requester's identity is uncertain
Your IT department members are considered workforce members if they are internal to your organization. If your IT department is outsourced, they are most likely a business associate. Both of them can access ePHI if it is required to do their job. Someone who is pretending to be your IT department does not have the authorization.
HIPAA's Security Rule requires you to have procedures in place to ensure that the individual or entity requesting access to ePHI "is the one claimed." It also states, you must have a security awareness and training program in place for your workforce and management.
Your Business Associate Agreement will state what your vendor can do with PHI. It will not tell you if the person you are emailing is actually your vendor. Also, your IT department shouldn't need patient information to resolve your ticket, so that should be a red flag as well.
Where HIPAA compliant email fits in the defense
Encrypting your email will help keep your patients' PHI secure when it leaves your organization. The Security Rule lists encrypting your transmissions as an addressable specification. You need to decide whether to encrypt your email and document the reasoning. If someone is impersonating your IT department to an employee, encryption will not help you.
Filtering incoming emails can help you prevent impersonation of your IT department to an employee. Paubox Inbound Email Security uses generative AI to analyze emails for impersonation. The ExecProtect+ feature can help identify if someone is using a spoofed display name or similar domain. You can find Paubox’s inbound email security in the Email Suite Plus and Premium plans. This will not keep you in compliance or guarantee that no phishing email will make it through to your employees.
You should also make sure your employees know to report phishing emails to your IT department. In a survey done by Paubox, 95% of phishing emails were not reported to the IT department.
Learn more: Impersonation attacks in healthcare email communication
What email controls and training cannot establish
No amount of email security will stop someone from calling your help desk and pretending to be an employee. If they are able to talk your help desk into adding them to an employee's device, they will pass all the MFA requirements that you have in place. This will have to be done by your IT department calling the number that is on file before they can help an employee with a password reset or device enrollment. Like what was recommended in the health sector alert was sent out in 2024.
One study at a US healthcare organization required employees who clicked on five or more simulated phishing emails to complete training. The training did not meaningfully lower their click rates, although click rates fell for all employees over time. Across 20 campaigns, only 17.9% of employees never clicked.
Simulated phishing tests can only tell you how many of your employees will click on an email. They can't tell you what your employees will do if someone calls them and has their information.
FAQs
Is a successful IT impersonation attack a reportable HIPAA breach?
When an impersonator accesses a mailbox containing PHI, HIPAA presumes a breach unless a documented risk assessment shows a low probability the PHI was compromised.
What should an employee do after entering credentials on a fake IT page?
Report it to the real IT or security team immediately so they can reset the password, end active sessions, and check the mailbox for new forwarding rules.
What is the difference between phishing and vishing?
Phishing arrives by email, while vishing uses a phone call or voicemail to pressure someone into sharing credentials or approving access.
