HIPAA compliant email for fertility and reproductive treatment

Fertility treatment and assisted reproductive technology (ART) services represent some of the most emotionally sensitive and clinically complex areas in healthcare. Whether dealing with IVF, egg or sperm donation, or surrogacy, patients are often stepping into unfamiliar territory, trusting their providers not only with highly personal information but also their hopes of building a family. 

Digital communication, especially email, has become a lifeline for many healthcare providers and patients. For fertility and ART clinics, email can help streamline care coordination, support informed decision-making, and maintain a continuous connection throughout the patient journey. To truly serve its purpose in this setting, email must be HIPAA compliant. The sensitive nature of reproductive health data requires secure communication that protects patient privacy while enhancing the overall experience of care.

Understanding fertility treatment

According to VARTA, “There are many types of fertility treatments available, ranging from simple interventions such as medication to help a person ovulate, to more complicated procedures known as assisted reproductive treatment (ART). ART, also known as assisted reproductive technology, refers to medical and scientific methods used to help people conceive.” Fertility treatment may be used “to treat subfertility and infertility, to help people who identify as LGBTQIA+, and single people have children, for people who are unable to become pregnant, carry a pregnancy or give birth, to reduce the chance of a child inheriting a genetic disease or abnormality, [and] to preserve fertility.” The appropriate treatment will depend on the cause of infertility and should be discussed with a fertility specialist, as “this information provides a general overview of the techniques available.” 

Meeting patients where they are

A recent study in BMC Women’s Health found that “approximately 13% of women in the United States of reproductive age seek infertility services.” For many, this is their first direct experience with reproductive medicine, and the learning curve can be steep. The same study noted that “many people are unfamiliar with infertility healthcare before becoming patients” and that they “possess large knowledge gaps about treatment and may have difficulty understanding ART care.”

The lack of clarity often leads patients to look elsewhere. In fact, 87.8% of participants in the study said they searched the internet for more information, and yet “29.1% reported that they still did not find the answers they were looking for after searching online.” What patients want, it turns out, is authoritative guidance directly from their providers. “Participants reported a preference for using clinic-provided information to learn about care,” the study found. They turned to academic sources next but often struggled with the complexity. When that failed, those seeking guidance often looked to the internet and social media with limited success.

Clinics have an opportunity to close the knowledge gap. As the study recommends, “ART clinics can consider providing patients with more information related to cost, insurance, and mental health support tools.” HIPAA compliant email is an ideal way to do that. Clinics can use secure messaging to share FAQs, cost breakdowns, decision aids, or even checklists tailored to each stage of care, meeting patients where they are and delivering the clarity they’re seeking.

A more flexible, responsive way to deliver care

Email can also enhance day-to-day communication between patients and care teams. A study in Fertility and Sterility outlines multiple advantages of electronic messaging in fertility care. On the patient side, it offers flexibility: “Patients often wish to provide previous medical records or test results in advance of a telehealth or in-person visit.” On the provider side, it facilitates timely responses, helping teams relay lab results, treatment instructions, or clarification on the next steps without waiting for the next appointment.

The same study points out that email enables patients to ask follow-up questions they may have forgotten to bring up in person. It allows physicians “to elaborate on specific information that needs further clarification and offer another telehealth or an in-person visit to better serve the patient if the issue isn’t resolved by the email exchange.”

Other benefits include:

• Increased availability: Electronic messaging “can improve the perception of provider and staff availability,” especially when in-person appointments are limited.
• Faster turnaround: “Standard reporting of results through templates may reduce the time needed to inform patients of test results.”
• Reduced visits: Messaging allows clinics to “decrease the number of patient visits” by relaying non-urgent information via email. This reduces exposure risk during infectious disease outbreaks and can also help lower patient costs without compromising quality of care.

Best practices for implementing HIPAA compliant email in ART clinics

To ensure effective and secure communication, fertility clinics should follow best practices for HIPAA compliance in email use:

• Use a HIPAA compliant email service provider: Clinics should adopt platforms that offer encryption, such as Paubox.
• Obtain patient consent: Under HIPAA, providers must inform patients of the risks of electronic communication and obtain consent before using email to share PHI. This consent should be documented and renewed periodically.
• Establish clear email policies: Clinics should define what types of communication are appropriate for email, such as appointment reminders or non-urgent lab results, and which should be delivered through other channels. Response time expectations should also be set with patients.
• Implement access controls and audits: Only authorized personnel should have access to email accounts that send or receive PHI. Systems should include role-based access, audit logs, and automatic timeout settings.
• Train all staff regularly: Clinic staff should undergo routine training on HIPAA rules, email etiquette, phishing risks, and how to handle sensitive reproductive health information.
•  

Addressing challenges and limitations

While HIPAA compliant email has clear benefits for fertility and ART clinics, it’s not without its challenges. Understanding these limitations is beneficial to using email effectively without compromising care, overwhelming staff, or creating misunderstandings with patients.

One of the most common issues is unrealistic patient expectations. As noted in Fertility and Sterility, “Patients who receive a rapid reply to a sent email during office hours on a weekday may falsely believe that their email will receive the same attention 24 hours a day, 7 days a week even if counseled to the contrary.” Clinics should communicate that email is not meant for urgent concerns, and consider including reminders in email footers or automated responses.

Another risk is the assumption that one contact person is always available. Patients may build a relationship with a specific staff member and rely solely on them for communication, even in time-sensitive situations. “A patient may unrealistically believe that they can rely on a single individual with whom they correspond to have email access every day,” the article notes. If that person is out of the office, patients may delay reaching out through more appropriate channels, which can impact care.

Gaps in team communication are another concern. If emails aren’t properly documented or shared with the full care team, important details can fall through the cracks. “Not all interchanges may be captured in the medical record, leading to misunderstandings and gaps or errors in patient care,” the authors warn. Clinics should have clear protocols for logging email communication and looping in all relevant team members.

Security and privacy remain top priorities, even with HIPAA compliant systems. “Information may be viewed by individuals other than the patient without the patient’s permission” especially if emails are accessed on shared devices or accounts. It’s necessary for clinics to educate patients about the risks of shared access and encourage secure practices on their end as well.

Our solution

HIPAA compliant email simplifies communication in fertility clinics and ART programs, allowing providers to share time-sensitive updates such as lab results, cycle schedules, and medication instructions securely and efficiently.

Built-in encryption and access controls safeguard sensitive patient data without complicating the user experience. Solutions like Paubox Email Suite deliver encrypted messages directly to patients’ inboxes, removing the need for portals or extra logins. Advanced security features, including protection against phishing and spoofing, help shield both providers and patients from cyber threats.

Seamless integration with EHR systems, Google Workspace, and Microsoft 365 streamlines coordination between clinical teams, labs, and patients. Secure email communication supports timely decision-making, enhances patient engagement, and ensures HIPAA compliance without disrupting existing workflows.

Learn more: HIPAA Compliant Email: The Definitive Guide

FAQs

Can HIPAA compliant email be used to discuss embryo storage, donor information, or surrogacy arrangements?

Yes, but only when the email platform is fully HIPAA compliant and both parties have agreed to electronic communication. These topics involve highly sensitive PHI and sometimes third-party involvement, so documentation, access control, and secure archiving are necessary.

How can fertility clinics reduce email overload from patients without discouraging communication?

Set clear communication expectations from the start. Consider using templated responses, patient handouts, or email auto-replies that clarify office hours, appropriate topics for email, and when a phone call or appointment is more appropriate.

What happens if a patient forwards a secure clinic email to someone else?

Once a patient receives an email, HIPAA protections don’t apply to what they choose to do with it. However, clinics should still advise patients not to forward messages containing sensitive PHI unless absolutely necessary, and never to use shared devices or accounts when discussing care.

Is consent to email PHI a one-time process, or does it need to be renewed?

The best practice is to document consent at intake and review it periodically especially if the patient’s care plan changes or they express concerns about digital communication. Consent forms should also note that email isn’t a substitute for emergency communication.

Can fertility clinics use HIPAA compliant email for marketing or informational newsletters?

Only if it’s handled through a platform that supports HIPAA compliant marketing email (like Paubox Marketing). Generic platforms like Mailchimp or Constant Contact are not HIPAA compliant unless they sign a BAA and offer encryption; most do not.