Confidentiality in healthcare is a foundational principle, but there are critical circumstances where it may be ethically and legally appropriate to breach confidentiality.
What is confidentiality?
Confidentiality is healthcare professionals' ethical and legal obligation to safeguard sensitive information shared by patients. It ensures that personal and private details disclosed during medical consultations or treatments are kept secure and not disclosed to unauthorized individuals or entities without the patient's explicit consent.
Maintaining confidentiality fosters trust, encourages open communication, and protects patient privacy. Legal and ethical standards govern it to protect patient information and respect their autonomy and privacy. Breaching confidentiality is only justified in specific circumstances where there's a severe threat to the patient or others, legal mandates require disclosure or public health concerns require sharing information to prevent harm.
Related: What are the confidentiality rules in therapy?
When can healthcare professionals break confidentiality?
There are a limited number of reasons breaking confidentiality is allowed in healthcare.
Imminent Danger
Sexual assault: If a patient discloses being a victim of sexual assault and is at risk of further harm, breaching confidentiality might be necessary. This includes situations where the victim is a minor, incapacitated, or vulnerable, requiring intervention to ensure their safety and well-being.
Murder or violence: Instances where a patient confesses intent or involvement in a murder or violent act demand careful consideration. If there's a genuine threat to the safety of an individual, breaching confidentiality might be justified to prevent harm.
Meeting legal obligations
In cases where the law requires disclosure, such as reporting cases of abuse, neglect, or complying with court orders, healthcare professionals have a legal obligation to breach confidentiality.
Public Health Concerns
When a patient's condition poses a significant risk to public health, like contagious diseases or outbreaks, disclosing information protects the wider community.
Related:
Balancing Act: Ethical Considerations
In all these scenarios, healthcare professionals face an ethical dilemma—balancing the duty to maintain confidentiality against the obligation to prevent harm. The decision to breach confidentiality should always be guided by careful assessment, involving consultations with peers, ethical committees, or legal experts whenever feasible.
Tshedimoso Makhene
